Random Sig Battle

[Guest Levy]

I got an idea about an hour and a half hour ago. I asked Xepha if she would have a little sig creation battle with me. She accepted.

The topic of the sigs was chosen by Dillon. His favorite game, The Sims.

About an hour or so later, we finished the sigs and its time to see who wins.

 

The creator of the sigs will remain secret, either me or Xepha. Though, you can probably tell by the very different styles who made them, if you pay attention to that sorta thing.

 

So decide which one you like best!

 

1.

 

2.

[Dillon]

I picked the top one because theres too much going on in the bottom on.

[The Big Cheese]

I posting first! :grrr:

 

aaaand its tied

 

I find the top one a bit boring, theres not much going on and it doesnt incorperate anything other than a picture whereas the bottom one includes the logo. Otherwise they're both great!

[Dillon]

I think theres too much green in the bottom one.

 

I know whos is who

 

Should I say?

[Guest Levy]

Should I say?

No, spoil-sport. I would rather this be non-biased.

[Xepha]

Yeah, no say please!

This is a secret until we get enough votes XD

 

 

Obliviously, I know which one is mine...

[Dillon]

I know which one is yours too!

[Guest Levy]

I know which one is yours too!

Well I think it is pretty obvious, though it would be freakin' hilarious if you guessed wrong.

[Ruto]

I like the bottom one. The top is...too simple. Just like my signatures! xD

[torridity]

I like both of them, but the top one more.

I'm all for simplicity :)

[Guest Levy]

Ok, its been a week and it looks like I've won. X3

It was just a fun little spur of the moment idea I had out of boredom.

 

They were both done within an hour so that is why they don't look as could as they could have been.

 

I see no reason for this to be closed though. By all means, if you haven't voted yet then vote. But odds are, the outcome won't change. And I learned some things from your comments that may impact my future of making sigs.

[smumpkins]

I prefer the second image, because the first image is difficult to recognize on first glance, while the second choice shows images that make it obvious as to what you're seeing. Plus, the colors for the first image are kind of dull, while the green in the second choice just makes the image... oh, what's the word... POP!

[Xepha]

I was in a sexy mood when I made the siggy (that is the number 1... yeah)

It's the only sims picture I found that was appealing me... and I meant to do it plain and simple.

 

Voilà.