November 21, 201114 yr i love cake (especially chocolate cake or angel cake with lemon frosting) but i do love apple crumble and apple pie with vanilla ice-cream.. *sudden cravings*
November 21, 201114 yr I only like Red Velvet cake, but even then, anyone who said anything other than sweet, glorious pie, is WRONG! RED VELVET FTW SO much colour but yea, it's one of the better cakes. :)
November 23, 201114 yr I like to take apart pies when I eat them. I do the same for cakes, depending on the types. I think cakes are less messy.
November 23, 201114 yr Hm...I really like pie...but then again I like more types of cake since i only like apple and pumpkin pies...so cake! Especially carrot cake. Love carrot cake. :wub_anim:
November 26, 201114 yr There are all different kinds of cake, which is what I like about them. And they come in all shapes and sizes, and can have stuff in them, but I don't know of any pies that have bits in the pastry rather than inside.
November 26, 201114 yr Cake for me, please! Ahh, cakes. They taste so good. Especially chocolate cakes! They also have cream unlike in pies.
November 29, 201114 yr Cake, definitely. I don't like pie unless it's lemon or chocolate-filled. I also don't like the fact that you can't really decorate pies. Well, you can probably but it wouldn't be as fun as decorating a cake (or cupcakes). Exactly! Cake is so much fun to decorate and the possibilities are endless! Cupcakes, cake pops, bundt cakes, layer cakes, etc. Then you can have fun with the type and color of icing, and do fillings, then sprinkles and all sorts of other garnishes! Ah... I love baking cakes. :) I just made a german chocolate cake this weekend as well as mini pumpkin cupcakes with cream cheese icing. Mmmm.... But, pie? Seriously, all you can do is cut out shapes with the dough to create a design or do a lattice top. Plus cake is far more enjoyable to eat. Cake rules!
November 30, 201114 yr Well im lactose intolerant so I will have to go with pie, Usually if a cake doesn't have milks its pretty gross, but you can make a pie dairy free and it still tastes awesome! plus you just can;t beat that syrupy filling :laughingsmiley:
February 20, 201214 yr My faves are: pumpkin, key lime, cherry, pecan, chocolate, blueberry and lemon pie
February 20, 201214 yr I enjoy them both but Pie won it for me. See, in a lot of cakes, there's this gross buttery icing I don't tend to like. It's very popular and cakes are just PASTED with it. I can't stand it. But warm apple pie, with it's inviting crust and mixed with cold whip cream; that's paradise. I also enjoy Pumpkin Pie around Thanksgiving and Halloween, again with Whip Cream. My favourite cake are cheese cakes, but those are a bit too thick. I don't mind lemon pie, though it's a bit sugary, I generally like the texture.
February 20, 201214 yr Definitely cake! I looove chocolate with buttercream frosting and angel food cake, but not really any other flavors. Pies are just gross to me. I don't like the chunky texture of most and don't like the taste of pie crust. I can stand to eat chocolate silk pie but that's it for me. Now, cheesecake is what I really like *.* Comes in so many delicious flavors with nice smooth texture. Not sure if they fit in the cake category or not. :P
February 21, 201214 yr I was going to choose cake and then decided that I couldn't vote because I really enjoy both of them! I really like Ice Cream Cake, but chocolate cake is good with me too- although I'm not a huge fan of most of the commercial grocery store icing. I also really enjoy Lemon Meringue pie and Cherry Pie filling, oh and Pecan pie is good too. THERE ARE SO MANY OPTIONS!
February 23, 201214 yr Well I don't eat either. Don't like creams or fillings. But I voted for cake. I like to bake them :)
February 23, 201214 yr So it might seem ridiculous, but I am very pleased to see that cake is winning. Cake is just so much more fun to try things with! Although I must admit that I am contemplating making some miniature pies in a mini cupcake pan. I expect them to look adorable, but still not quite as yummy as mini cupcakes...
February 26, 201214 yr I do not like pumpkin pie. At all. I just...I can't even...I'm sorry guys! I've tried it before and I just don't like the taste. But if anyone wants a piece of virtual Lemon Meringue pie, let me know! :)
February 27, 201214 yr I love pies, but I like cakes, too. Just yesterday I ate a piece of chocolate cake. u.u
February 28, 201214 yr Pies are amazing. I used to be in love with apple pies, but I'm diversifying into other types. Cakes are always just way too heavy for me.
March 17, 201214 yr i prefer cheesecake :) not sure if that falls under pie? haha Haha I think it's kind of it's own separate thing. How unique! ^_^ I looooove cheesecake. I also love both cake and pie, but I think cake wins out. Especially cupcakes - they're so fun to decorate.
March 19, 201214 yr Cake has better variety overall, but pie wins because of banana creme. Can't compete with that. Also, chicken pot pie. Can cake meat? I don't think so.
March 22, 201214 yr I hate cake. My tastes lean toward the savoury side so I'm firmly for pie. Meat pie is always awesome. *homer drooling noise*
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.