Reputation Activity
-
Zooba got a reaction from jasper_111 in Religion: Good or Bad?-Medieval times are known as the dark ages, most christians were illiterate, and the church was corrupt and rich. Nobody knew how to question people who were richer and smarter than they were. Once people started getting educated, more and more went against the corrupt church.
-Maybe it isn't the teaching of abstinence (as opposed to safe sex) that's the problem, maybe it's the way it's taught. Where I'm from, we are expected to abstain from sex before we marry and we do. They don't have to do much convincing to be honest...no offense but there is a lot of media coverage of teen pregnancies in western countries and if the girls don't give up the baby for adoption, they've basically ruined their future. Also, safe sex isn't 100% safe.
-You forget that creationism was and still is a valid theory, as is evolution. The highest degree of scientific recognition is to call something a theory, and before evolution came along, creationism was the most popular. Just because evolution is the most popular today doesn't mean that creationism is 100% wrong. In the end, despite scientific progression, nobody has figured out where the "energy" that makes us all tick comes from or where it goes when we die. To this day, we don't know what causes our hearts to beat, we've broken down the sequence of events and, to some degree, the mechanism, but "step 1" is simultaneous (AKA nobody knows how/why it starts/stops beating).
-
I actually find this a bit insulting, I'm religious, I like my faith, I don't give two hoots if you decide to convert or not. Religion is a personal relationship between a person and God. I have absolutely nothing to do with your relationship, or lack thereof, with God. If your government is enforcing laws you don't find fair, or you find discriminatory, take it up with them, not the entire global religious community.
-If I remember correctly, the original language of the bible was latin? If speaking your native language was against christianity, the entire western world would be talking latin now, and not english. It was translated to english centuries after christianity was established. The immigrants to the "new world" weren't forcing their language and culture on the native because of God, but that's how they chose to justify it.
-Children are taught religion early to teach them morality (I realize that you don't think religion teaches correct morality, but I do believe so). I don't think that that is a bad thing, and I don't think it's "ingrained" in their minds. Look at your case, you said you were raised catholic, you chose to shed religion later in life. As for their childhood, how is this belief any different from raising your children vegans or vegetarians? You raise them however you want to, once they become adults, it's up to them. That is your right as a parent. If religion was truly ingrained in children's minds, nobody would ever become an atheist.
-As a source of Evil...
I don't think religion is the source of the evil that happens in its name. The source is humanity, justifying their actions. Religion calls murder a sin, murder in religion's name doesn't make it not a sin.
In the end I think it all winds down to a few fundamental issues:
-Whether you believe in the existence of a greater power.
-Whether you think religion is man-made or created by God.
-Whether, even if you do believe in a greater power, you think that modern religion is corrupt.
We seem to disagree on the most important of those issues, the first one. That's the impression I've gotten at least.
Another thing I've noticed is that after condemning catholicism and deciding you didn't like it, you chose to condemn all of religion with it as well.
Anyways, I'm off now, it's been interesting talking with you all :)
-
Zooba got a reaction from jasper_111 in Religion: Good or Bad?I think we'll have to agree to disagree on that point. I don't think you can hold the religion itself responsible for the piety (can't think of a more accurate word...religiousness?) , or lack thereof, of its followers. They may represent the faith in day to day situations, in small ways, but not in general. Lots of christians have sex before marriage, does that mean that christianity condones it? Are they really representing their religion? or themselves as individuals? I choose to view religion as the idea, not the people because if I viewed it as the people, it wouldn't have a definition at all. Everyone has different levels of spirituality and faith and have different degrees of adhering to the laws set by that faith. There are more religious people and less religious people, they aren't all clones.
I should also mention that I don't think fear is the mechanism of how religion works. I think that religion gives people hope and faith in a higher power that they can pray to. I can't say how often I'm soothed when I pray or think that God is protecting me. The fear aspect does exist though, and I'm trying to acknowledge it. I don't think that it's the major feeling that is evoked by having faith though.
Also, the reason I think fear is effective in religion is the divine, inevitable aspect of it, and the fact that the person believes in it in their hearts. I highly doubt that "worldly" fear would work in the same way, you can trick people, but you can't trick God.
-
Zooba got a reaction from Angeló in Religion: Good or Bad?@passiflora I honestly don't think it would matter the presence or lack of religion a bad person is raised in, what matters is how they were raised. Terrorism and murder and rape are all sins, in all religions, does that mean that when a "religious person" does them in the name of religion, the religion actually supports the sin "under those circumstances". It doesn't, it just means that the way that person was raised, they've been taught that that is okay. I dunno if I explained it well, but it all goes down to proper parents instilling the correct morals in their child.
Personally, I think the morals taught by religion are correct, and they're the most effective. If you don't think that God is watching you, what's to stop you from committing crimes? The law? What's a more powerful motivator, punishment from mortals or punishment from an all-knowing all-powerful God? I think it's more effective (when the rules are followed correctly, which they usually aren't) at reducing crime than encouraging people to rely on their own judgement. Not everyone has the same basic instincts when it comes to right and wrong, that's why criminals exist.
I get that not everyone thinks the morals taught by religion are right, but to each his/her own :)
-
Zooba reacted to The Bandit in Religion: Good or Bad?There are a lot of comments on here saying religion is overall a bad thing, which makes me sad, especially when pretty much all religions were started with the aim of making the world a better place. I can see where people are coming from, a huge amount of bad stuff has been done in the name of religion, from Muslim terrorists today, going all the way back to Christianity and the Crusades, and also the Catholic suppression of scientists like Galileo.
However, looking at my own country, the UK, I firmly believe that without Christianity it would be a far worse place than it is today. Our historical legal system and laws are basically based on the Bible. A significant amount of the first hospitals and decent schools were started by Christians, and the abolition of the Slave Trade and the setting up of fair working practices in Victorian Times was also down to Christians like Shaftesbury and Wilberforce. Even today, a lot of the best charities are run by Christians or have Christian foundations.
Fundamentally, I don't like thinking about my 'religion', Christianity', as a 'religion' at all - it should be about having a relationship with God. It's when people start forgetting what God wants, and making it what they want, with all the traditions and rules and regulations, that the problems begin.
-
Zooba got a reaction from Finn the Human in Religion: Good or Bad?Like some people have already mentioned: a bad religious person will still be a bad person if you somehow convince them to become an atheist. Religion in and of itself preaches basic morality (in my opinion, I realize a lot of people don't agree with it) and I believe that without religion, the world would not be a better place.
As for the arguments that people pick and choose etc., well that isn't religion's fault, thats the person's fault. Not that I'm judging them either, we've got a phrase that they say a lot where I'm from: You've got your sins, and I've got mine. Basically, you can't judge a person for doing something that is considered a sin in their religion, because most probably you also commit sins, who gets to decide if your sins are better or worse than another persons.
Also, I don't think it's mere coincidence that all of the world's major religions preach the same basic concepts, have the same things that the consider sins, have variations of the same "biblical" stories (Noah's ark, Adam and Eve, etc.)
At the same time, I get that some people don't like religion, and tbh I don't care what happens to their souls, they can do and believe whatever the hell they like as long as it isn't affecting me.
I do get annoyed when people who pick and choose bits of religion to follow decide that it's okay for them to go around and tell everyone that they're version of religion is better than another, or to justify the sins they choose to do...if you want to sin, go ahead, but don't tell me that I'm wrong for not committing the same sins you choose to commit.
I also get annoyed when people (mostly online) bash religion, and I mean bashing, not discussion or debate, no, full on, caps-lock, excessive punctuation bashing. I'm not a christian, but when I see people bashing christianity or judaisim or islam....it all feels just as bad to me. And the disappointing thing is that a lot of people somehow believe that just because they don't believe something, it makes it okay for them to talk **** about it. Calling religion brain-washing, calling people who have a religion idiots....*sigh* it hurts a lot of people, and I don't think people realize that.
In the end no religion can dictate whether a person is a jerk or not. And what a lot of people overlook is that there are non-religious terrorist groups out there too (KKK anyone?) I don't doubt there are more, but religious terrorism 'sells' better.
-
Zooba got a reaction from karmacow in Doctor WhoI just recently watched the new seasons last June, starting with the 2005 one with the 9th Doctor. I loved the 9th Doctor, and I felt like David Tennant really pulled off the transformation into the 10th Doctor. They both have the same...feel..to the character, like you can really believe that the same Doctor is talking through a different body. Matt Smith is good I suppose, but it feels like the Doctor I've come to know and love has gotten a complete personality transplant. 9th and 10th doctors are my favorites, it's a tie.
Favorite companion is definitely Rose.
-
Zooba reacted to The_Warblers in Religion: Good or Bad?Humans are just humans, greedy, jealousy, selfish .... So even there were / are no such things as religious war in humans' history. There are still wars anyway.
So religion is good when the followers are good. And vice versa
-