So, I was searching up random names to see if they were taken, when I stumbled upon Starrye and Starlighte in the pound. But since their names are so similar and I am running out of room, I've decided to keep only one of them. I'm really torn about who to keep. Any opinions?

Generally opinion is that shorter names are better but I just think Starlighte is so much prettier. Starrye is also nice but it doesn't roll off the tongue as nicely.. do you say it like star-ye or starry?

Hmmm...when I adopted Starrye I pronounced it "starry", but I see what you mean by the ambiguity surrounding how to say it.

 

Edit: If anyone is interested, I've decided to keep Starlighte.