Shade McCoy

All six worked for me, and I'm in GMT-7. I scored:

2x Spyder Wardrobe

3x Roast Tentacle

Eye of Mortog Soup

Toy Spider Ring

Ichor Ghost Toast

Kacheeps

Chocolate Covered Onion

Spooky Gooplecream

Chocolate Korbat Ice Lolly

This was from 4 "Spooky" and two "Ghosty" bags.

in the guessing part? why isn't Orrin one of the possiblities? are they just telling you that he didn't do it? his story is one of the most suspicious! :S

Because he was locked in storage all night, remember? He never came out until the captain sent for him the next day.

It's going to be Maraqua, most likely. Did anyone else notice this?

http://www.neopets.com/water/statue.phtml

Look familiar?